Roofing crew repairing a Long Island roof after storm damage

Wind takes a Brookhaven roof apart from the edges — the eaves, the ridge, the gable ends, the flashing — and takes siding off the face that took the gusts, and then the rain that follows goes into the sheathing and the wall behind. Alec's Construction tarps and boards the same day where we can reach you, finds the wet sheathing that a cosmetic patch would cover up, and rebuilds the roof, the siding and the gutters on one scope with the interior, working out of the yard on Barton Avenue in East Patchogue.

What a Storm Does in Brookhaven

The hamlet of Brookhaven — the old village at the mouth of the Carmans River, not the town that took its name — is low, wet and old. The river opens into Bellport Bay here, the Wertheim marsh wraps the south side, and the streets off Beaver Dam Road and South Country Road run down to the water on ground that is only a few feet above it. A surge comes up the river and across the marsh at the same time. The housing is some of the oldest on the South Shore — shingle and clapboard houses from the 1800s and early 1900s on stone and brick foundations, with full basements that fill — mixed with 1950s and 60s ranches nearer the highway. The old houses have big trees that were planted with them.

Wind Off the Bay

Roofs along the bay take the wind head-on from the south and southeast with nothing between them and the water. The eaves and the ridge go first, then the siding on the bay face, and the rain that follows goes into the sheathing. Salt spray on the exposed sheathing and fasteners is one more reason the wet material comes out rather than dries in place.

What Wind Does to a Roof Here

Shingles lift at the eaves and the ridge first, where the wind gets under them. Once a course goes, the ones above it follow, and the rain that comes after the wind goes through the exposed underlayment into the sheathing, the attic insulation and the ceilings below. Flashing at chimneys and sidewalls pulls loose. Gutters and fascia peel off the eaves and take the drip edge with them. A roof that "just lost a few shingles" is usually wet under a wider area than the missing shingles show.

What Wind Does to Siding

Vinyl unlocks and sails off in panels from the windward face and from the corners. The housewrap behind it tears, and the sheathing behind that takes rain until the panels are back. Cedar and clapboard split at the fasteners. The repair is not the panels; it is the wrap and the sheathing behind them, dried and checked before anything goes back on.

The Order of Work

Photographs as found. Tarp and board the same day where we can reach you. Wet insulation and sheetrock out from under the leak. Sheathing opened where it is wet and replaced where it has to be. Then the roof, the flashing, the siding, the gutters and the interior on one scope, the cause corrected so the new work stays dry.

Emergency tarp over a damaged roof section on a Long Island house

The Claim

Wind damage to a roof or siding is a homeowners claim. Storm damage is separated from wear on the scope — the carrier pays for what the wind did, not for a roof that was at the end of its life — and where a roof is more storm than wear, the scope says so with the photographs to show it. We meet the adjuster at the house. Many coastal New York policies carry a separate deductible for named storms; the figure is on your declarations page.

Building Department in Brookhaven

The hamlet of Brookhaven files with the Town of Brookhaven at Independence Hill in Farmingville; the streets south of Montauk Highway along the Carmans River and Bellport Bay are in the mapped flood zone. Emergency work to make the house safe and dry does not wait for a permit; the permanent repair is filed once the scope is agreed.

Free walkthrough in Brookhaven. Call or text (631) 312-7441. Tell us whether the roof is open, whether a tree is on the structure and whether there is water inside, and we bring the right equipment on the first trip.

Frequently Asked Questions

My Brookhaven house is over a hundred years old. Does that change the storm repair?

It changes what is behind the wall. Old houses here have balloon framing, plank sheathing, horsehair plaster and stone or brick foundations that take water differently from a 1960s ranch, and the repair has to match what is there rather than what a modern house would have. Photographs as found, wet plaster and lath out where it has failed, the framing dried and metered, and a scope that names the actual materials so the adjuster prices the right thing.

Can you tarp the roof today?

Where we can reach you safely and the roof can be walked, yes, that is what the first visit is for. A tarp is a temporary measure to stop the water while the damage is documented and the permanent repair is scoped.

Will insurance pay to replace the whole roof or just the missing shingles?

It depends on what the wind did and what the adjuster sees. Where the damage is scattered across the roof, or the shingles that are left cannot be matched or will not seal, a full replacement is often the right scope and often the approved one. Where the damage is one section, it is a section. We write the scope from the photographs and meet the adjuster at the house.

The siding is gone on one side. Can you match it?

Sometimes, and when we can we do. Vinyl profiles and colours go out of production, and a house that lost a full face often gets that face re-sided in the closest match rather than patched with panels that do not match. What is behind the panels matters more: the wrap and the sheathing get dried and checked before anything goes back on.

Related Guides

Also Serving Brookhaven

Work With Alec's Construction

This guide is written by the crew that does the work. See Alec's Hurricane & Storm Damage Repair service — fallen trees, flooding, roof and siding damage, cleanup and the rebuild. Licensed and insured on Long Island, one crew start to finish, free walkthrough and a written estimate inside 48 hours.

Booking the cold months now: we also handle Roofing and Storm Damage & Insurance Restoration.

Get a Free Estimate from Alec's Construction

Licensed and insured, working across Nassau and Suffolk County since 2018. We come out, look at the actual job, and put a written number in your hand — no pressure, no obligation.

Or call (631) 312-7441

No cost, no obligation. We reply the same day.